The government protects you; the government hurts you

The deal was too good to be true, and fortunately for Charles Crocker, he realized that.

The brokerage unit of Stanford Group Co. in Dallas wanted to sell him certificates of deposit with a very high rate of return. But the money would have gone to Antiqua. Crocker wanted to keep his money at home. He did agree, however, to put his money in the financial empire of R. Allen Stanford, investing it in various accounts that were considered less risky.

R. Allen Stanford

R. Allen Stanford

He was right. The accounts were not risky, and Crocker is lucky. Unlike tens of thousands of Stanford customers who invested in the CDs, he didn’t lose his money. But that didn’t help much for seven weeks in 2009 when all of his accounts were frozen along with 50,000 other Stanford customers. A federal judge ordered the accounts blocked so the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission and others could investigate.

As detailed in the Sunday, July 19, 2009 Watchdog column in the Fort Worth Star-Telegram by Dave Lieber, the government actually ended up hurting Crocker and others more than Stanford ever did.

Nobody would answer his questions about when he could get his money. Even after his $400,000 in life savings was restored, along with access to his Social Security payments, nobody will talk to him about how he can get reimbursed for the nearly $1,000 in penalty fees for checks that bounced when the Stanford accounts were frozen without Crocker’s knowledge.

He also doesn’t know if his credit will be restored.

How horrible to be hurt by your own government, those who have sworn to protect you. Imagine going nearly two months without access to your money because of an investigation. Crocker showed Watchdog Nation a thick binder of letters to government officials of all stripes. Nobody but nobody would help him.

His congresswoman, U.S. Rep. Kay Granger, R-Fort Worth, for example, referred him to the court-appointed receiver, who refused to answer e-mails, phone calls or letters.

The only thing worse is losing all your money, which happened to so many.

Here’s an amazing report that details the perfidy and corruption of the Stanford empire, including how the top regulator in Antiqua was bribed to falsify documents and stave off the SEC.

Now that ace TV pitchman Billy Mays is gone, all eyes should turn to The SCOOTER Store guy

Now that TV huckster Billy Mays is gone, who can replace him as top pitchman on middle-of-the-night TV?

Watchdog Nation nominates Doug Harrison.

He’s the guy on The SCOOTER Store’s incessant TV commercials who makes that big promise about the free chair or scooter if you don’t qualify under Medicare.


Billy Mays

Billy Mays


Doug Harrison is founder and president of The SCOOTER Store and star of his own commercials. He promises that if you don’t  qualify for a scooter or power chair with government assistance – his exact words – “we’ll give you a new power scooter free.”

The SCOOTER Store’s marketing campaign is an example of advertising that takes you to the edge of the line but doesn’t cross over. Or does it?


Doug Harrison (Photo/thescooterstore.com)

Doug Harrison


That same Doug Harrison a couple of years ago agreed to make a $500,000 personal “contribution” to the federal government  to settle a huge civil lawsuit against The SCOOTER Store for violating the False Claims Act. The company paid another $4  million in fines and gave up Medicare claims worth about $13 million.

Harrison, the U.S. Justice Department stated in 2007, “also agreed to forego dividends from his shares in the company for the next year in exchange for a release of his personal liability.”

As a recent Watchdog column by Dave Lieber in the July 18, 2009 Fort Worth Star-Telegram reminded here, federal prosecutors accused The SCOOTER Store of engaging “in a multi-media advertising campaign to entice beneficiaries to obtain power scooters paid for by Medicare, Medicaid, and other insurers. Instead of the ‘zippy’ power scooters that were advertised, The SCOOTER Store sold the beneficiaries expensive power wheelchairs that they did not want, need and/or could not use.”

The government also accused The SCOOTER Store of selling used equipment as new and charging Medicare millions for unnecessary accessories.

As part of this, the company agreed to a 5-year corporate integrity program, monitored by the federal government.

When you examine the 2009 TV ad starring Harrison and the company’s latest marketing materials, the delicate use of  language stands out.

The promise of a free chair is still there, but it’s loaded with conditions:

“You may even get your power chair or scooter ABSOLUTELY FREE.”

“Your new power chair or scooter could cost you little to nothing.”

“If we pre-qualify you… we guarantee you will receive it FREE.”

And the ultimate qualifier: “This guarantee has some restrictions, is not available in all locations, and is subject to change.”

You may…

You could…

If…

Notice how these words, added as qualifiers after the Justice Department’s action, are not capitalized.

What is capitalized?

FREE… and… ABSOLUTELY FREE.

Over the line?

Do electricity regulators really regulate?

Watchdog Nation had a theory: Some electricity companies, despite Photo courtesy of centralillinoisproud.comhorrendous customer service, are getting away with it. But is the theory true?

Based on the hundreds of letters we receive each year at the Fort Worth Star-Telegram from people complaining about their electricity bills, we wondered what happened to the thousands of complaints about electricity companies that go to the Public Utility Commission of Texas each year.

Do the companies get penalized?

As The Watchdog columnist for the Fort Worth Star-Telegram, I conducted a study. Using the open-records law, we requested the total complaints from customers of three companies that had severe difficulties in the past two years – Amigo Energy, TXU Energy and Direct Energy. We studied the number of complaints, the number that were investigated and what action was taken against any offenders.

The findings are described in detail in Sunday’s Fort Worth Star-Telegram (7/12/09) here. And you can have the reprint of our Guide to Shopping for Electric Rates – requested already by thousands of people.

In summary, the best way to counter an electric company (or any company for that matter) that harms you is to complain, complain and complain. By forcing up complaint numbers, the trend lines show a problem, thereby making the regulators more likely to take strong action.

By the way, colleague Jack Z. Smith tells a much-needed story about how the elderly, especially, can shop for lower rates here.

Get better TV reception on old TV before spending money


If this guy holds my TV antenna, I bet I’d get a better picture.


We took this photo in San Francisco a long time ago. Silver Man wore clothing flecked with aluminum. Now we wish he could come to world headquarters of Watchdog Nation and stand and hold the antenna on the one remaining analog TV in our office suite that doesn’t pick up good reception after the analog-to-digital debacle.

All the words we read and wrote ourselves in the Fort Worth Star-Telegram about the digital TV debacle never took into account one little cure for some of  the upcoming TV problems.

Aluminum foil.

Why spend $50 for a more powerful digital TV antenna to add to the already stupid little black box that converts the signals when you can wrap some aluminum foil around the top of your old antenna, rescan the converter box and say a little prayer?

As we first reported in the Star-Telegram, we were so close to spending $50 at Radio Shack for a new antenna. But the Shack was out of product because everyone else  was spending the $50.

Then we heard about the aluminum foil trick.

We grabbed a sheet, wrapped it around the antenna ears, and voila! The two remaining major network channels we weren’t  receiving suddenly reappeared.

Remember: aluminum foil.

The government never told you about it because it is embarrassed.

As well it should be.

It’s the 1950s all over again.

Postscript: The aluminum foil still works, but the TV just broke.

Book judges love Dave Lieber’s Watchdog Nation

“Highly recommended.”

“Great book.”

“I loved this book.”

Judges of the 2009 Benjamin Franklin Awards spoke highly of Dave Lieber’s Watchdog Nation. The judges examined the book as part of the contest sponsored by the Independent Book Publishers Association.

“Great book,” Judge #1 wrote.

“Valuable tips!” wrote Judge #2. “I just kept flipping from page to page, case to case; laughing, learning from the lead watchdog. A really useful book!”

“I loved this book!” wrote Judge #3. “It addresses, in a very clear fashion, how to stop scammers, as well as how to resolve bill disputes with AT&T, the electric company, etc. His suggestions are clear and succinct: Use dogpile.com as an adjunct to Google. Research every company before doing business with them on the Web. Utilize librarians. Highly recommended.”

Dave is The Watchdog columnist for the Fort Worth Star-Telegram, one of the finest newspapers in Texas.

Watchdog Nation founder wins two national columnist awards

“Every city needs a Dave Lieber.”

That’s what one judge said when awarding Dave, founder of Watchdog Nation, one of his two national writing awards at the 2009 conference of the National Society of Newspaper Columnists.

Lieber, The Watchdog columnist for the Fort Worth Star-Telegram, one of Texas’ finest newspapers, won second place in the Herb Caen Memorial Items/Notes category and honorable mention for general-interest columns in newspapers with more than 100,000 circulation.

The general-interest columns were about a retired airline pilot who lost much of his life savings through scams, a government-sponsored research project that enrolled patients without their knowledge and a Baylor Health Care System employee whom hospital police believe stole $1.4 million. The notes columns were watchdog shorts about various items.

One judge commented, “Dave Lieber’s columns quickly and easily create a sense of outrage in a reader. He writes about rip-offs, scams and jerks who take advantage of the most vulnerable people in society. He exposes wrongs and wrong-doers. Every city needs a Dave Lieber.”

Another judge stated, “Members of the Fourth Estate play many important roles in society. Among them is that of ‘watchdog’ — the reporter/writer/editor who is adept at ‘afflicting the comfortable, and comforting the afflicted.’ Mr. Lieber fills that role very well.

“Mr. Lieber does not engage in the frequent chest thumping that accompanies many of the ‘I am on your side’ investigators who spend far too much time telling you how great they are rather than focusing on the problem.

“Mr. Lieber gets quickly to the point about who was wronged and how — and he does it covering topics of wide general interest. It’s a safe bet that businesses around Fort Worth read his articles faithfully — and with some trepidation.”

The columnists’ society (columnists.com), with 300 members, held its 33rd annual conference in Ventura, Ca. The group honored Jon Carroll of the San Francisco Chronicle with its Ernie Pyle Lifetime Achievement Award.

Full winners list here.

I am the victim of identity theft (again)

On the final day of 2008, I got a phone call, but it wasn’t someone with good wishes for the new year. The call was from a woman at a collection agency. She was stern and to the point: She asked me to repay $279 for a bounced check I had written at a Wal-Mart in Pearland.

Only I have never been to Pearland, and I don’t write checks at Wal-Mart.

My first thought: scam.

I asked for her company name, and she told me. When I asked for her name and her employee ID number, she refused, saying, “You’ll get a letter.” She hung up.

I did an Internet search for the company name — TRS Recovery — and the words Wal-Mart and bounced check.

A slew of comments came up.

One person reported a similar situation: bounced check in a Wal-Mart he never visited, and he doesn’t write checks.

His bank representative, he wrote, looked up TRS on the Internet and discovered that the company “is a fraud!” He complained that letters from the company “looked very real” and worried about people who have been “scammed by this company.” He added that he intended to file a police report against the company and also a complaint with the Federal Trade Commission.

After reading that and similar comments on another Web site, I thought that was all there was to it, and I could return to prepping for our New Year’s Eve celebration.

But a voice in my head asked, “What would The Watchdog do next?”

An unexpected twist

Next I checked the company’s Better Business Bureau report online.

What I found was unexpected and further proof that a lot of people write a lot of nonsense in blog postings. A scam? Hardly.

Turns out TRS Recovery is an affiliate of TeleCheck, which operates an electronic check verification system for retailers.

The BBB report shows 677 complaints against the company. Half are for billing and collection issues. But another statistic is one not found in a scam company. Of those 677 complaints, the number resolved is also 677. A company that cleans up its messes.

The free report listed company officials with phone numbers. I picked the top name on the list and called her – Denise Hossler, director of compliance.

New Year’s Eve. I figured I’d never get anyone. But Hossler picked up her phone.

She offered to help, and no, I didn’t tell her I’m The Watchdog. I wanted to see how she treated customers. I got lucky. This is someone who cares. When I complimented her on the perfect BBB record, she said that was her personal goal for the year.

Hossler looked up my file, and we figured out what happened.

Someone had bought $279 worth of merchandise at a Wal-Mart in Pearland last month using a fake check with my name and address. The check purported to be from a Harlingen credit union.

I was the victim of identity theft.

Happy New Year.

A victim again.

What did Yogi Berra supposedly say? Deja vu all over again.

Thirteen years ago, I tried to pay at a Wal-Mart in North Richland Hills, and the store declined my check. Turns out someone had written a check at a Montgomery Ward store in my name. Later, I learned another check was written at a toy store.

Took two days to clean things up. For two weeks, I wasn’t permitted to write checks. A state trooper told me that my driver’s license number was probably “pulled out of the air” by a con man.

Very few people become the victim of ID theft twice, says Linda Foley of the Identity Theft Resource Center. “You’ve been hit twice.”

Better that than lightning.

According to one study, Americans have a 1 in 37 chance of becoming an ID theft victim.

In Texas, a new legislative study shows that although half of all Texas ID theft victims lose no money, they spend between four and 130 hours fixing problems related to the theft. For those who do lose money, losses average $500.

Texas has laws to protect people in my situation. A debt collection company can’t hold me responsible for a debt I didn’t incur. Lenders can’t penalize me if I apply for loans or credit.

But what concerns me is the ease with which someone can pull this off. Fake checks — called synthesized checks — can be printed on a home computer.

I wondered about Wal-Mart’s procedures for verifying checks. Wal-Mart spokeswoman Ashley Hardie told me that check writers at Wal-Mart stores are randomly checked for additional information such as a driver’s license or a phone number when a cashier is prompted to ask for more information by the TeleCheck system. But this means that not all customers’ checks are verified.

Mike Prusinski, a spokesman for LifeLock, which provides loss protection for consumers, said big retailers that don’t demand more rigorous check verification are a major contributor to identity theft.

“If Wal-Mart and all the other places, instead of doing it randomly, did it all the time,” ID thieves would face tougher obstacles, he said.

Foley, of the ID Theft Resource Center, says, “Thieves know which companies don’t check things carefully and which ones do. They’re not stupid. This is their profession.”

Next, I’ll show you how I’m digging out of this hole.

PART TWO: WHEN IDENTITY THEFT HAPPENS, KNOW HOW TO FIGHT BACK

A few hours before the end of 2008, I found out that I was the victim of identity theft. I got a call from a collection agency seeking payment for a $279 check in my name payable to a Wal-Mart store in Pearland.

Only I didn’t write the check and I’ve never been to Pearland. This is the second time this has happened to me in 13 years.

I didn’t let it ruin my fun. I wasn’t angry or upset. I didn’t panic. I figured that whatever happens, I can deal with it. Then I tried to make as many calls as I could to learn what happened and do what I was supposed to do before the clock struck midnight.

It doesn’t take long to lay the groundwork to protect yourself when something like this happens. I kept a diary of my experience, and I’ll share it so you’ll know what to do if this happens to you.

1. I check out the collection agency – TRS Recovery – on the Internet. I discover that others have received similar calls. Several write that the TRS/Wal-Mart/bounced check story is a scam and that the company is taking money from innocent victims. But that turns out not to be true.

2. At the Better Business Bureau Web site, I learn that TRS is an affiliate of TeleCheck, a large check-processing company. The company has a perfect BBB record. 667 complaints. All of them resolved.

3. The BBB report lists phone numbers for company officials. I call the first one on the list — the director of compliance. Even though it is New Year’s Eve day, Denise Hossler answers her phone. She walks me through the facts, and I learn that this is a case of identity theft.

4. At her urging, I call workers at TRS’ fraud unit to register a dispute. I get a reference number. They tell me to get a Federal Trade Commission ID theft affidavit form from www.ftc.gov, fill it out and fax it to them to wipe the slate clean.

5. After downloading the affidavit from the FTC Web site, I complete it and take it to a notary. Notary public Stephanie Silva hears what has happened and says of ID thieves, “If they spent as much time doing honest work, they’d be millionaires.”

6. I call the FTC ID theft hot line (1-877-438-4338) to register for a national list of victims. I get another reference number.

7. The credit union where the check supposedly originated tells me the account with my name doesn’t exist. Someone used the credit union’s name but printed the check on his or her own. The credit union e-mails me a letter stating that.

8. The FTC affidavit is faxed to the debt collectors, along with the required proof of address (my Fort Worth water bill). But I receive no verification that it arrives. So I call back and ask for the mailing address so I can send it certified, return-receipt requested. They say that’s not necessary. I do it anyway.

9. When I call the Wal-Mart store to report the theft, I’m placed on hold. Eventually, I hang up. Later, Wal-Mart’s media relations department puts me in touch with a Wal-Mart risk-assessment employee, who takes a formal report. (A Wal-Mart spokeswoman says that ID theft victims should report incidents to the store involved.)

10. I call the Brazoria County Sheriff’s Department, which covers that Wal-Mart, to file a complaint, but I’m told to contact my hometown police department. Fort Worth police take my complaint and give me a police report number, which I’m told is the most important reference number of all. I’ll file an open-records request with the city to get a copy of the actual report.

11. I call LifeLock (phone: 1-877-Lifelock), a company that provides me with limited ID theft protection for $10 a month. A representative tells me that if I lose any money, LifeLock will cover it and that if I ever have a problem clearing my credit report, the company will work on that, too.

12. At the Identity Theft Resource Center’s Web site (www.idtheftcenter.org), I read informative articles about ID theft. Then I call the center’s Victim Assistance Center (1-858-693-7935) and talk to an adviser. She reminds me that this is not going to ruin my life, hurt my credit score or take money out of my pocket.

Most people, she says, “are very upset. They don’t know what to do. They’ve never had this situation happen to them. They ask, “How dare anyone do this to me?”

13. I call Linda Foley, a leader at the ID Theft Center, to ask more questions. She recommends that I call the three major credit bureaus and put a fraud alert on my credit to prevent anyone from opening a line in my name. Anyone can get an alert for 90 days before renewing, but as an ID theft victim, I can get it for seven years. She also suggests that I ask the bureaus for a security freeze so no one can access my credit report without my permission. (TransUnion, 800-680-7289; Equifax, 800-525-6285; Experian, 888-397-3742).

Foley predicts that as credit tightens, thieves will turn to check fraud. Unlike a credit card account, which can be closed, a check writer can keep writing fake checks. Every time a fake check pops up somewhere with my name, I’ll have to answer it by sending that FTC affidavit to the merchant as my explanation.

When does this end for the thousands like me who endure this? Probably when stores put in check-processing systems that can show cashiers a photo of the rightful holder of a checking account, Foley says.

No photo match? Then no purchase.

Meanwhile, I’ll keep you posted.

Core Principles of Watchdog Nation

The idea behind the growing consumer movement is simple: With money tight and scammers everywhere, anyone who buys anything must be on guard. Consumers today are smart to rely on five core principles to keep them out of trouble.

Simple to remember but often forgotten, these principles are the backbone of Watchdog Nation, a growing group of Americans who rely on sound research, accountability and ultimately, smart strategies to fight back and win when businesses and scammers try to hurt them.

That’s the philosophy behind Watchdog Nation, according to Fort Worth Star-Telegram investigative columnist Dave Lieber, whose new book on Watchdog Nation recently won a national book award.

Dave Lieber’s Watchdog Nation: Bite Back When Businesses and Scammers Do You Wrong is the winner of the 2009 Next Generation Indie Book Award for Social Change.

“I get about 50 letters and calls a week from people with problems needing my help,” Lieber says. “As a columnist, I can only handle two. It breaks my heart that I can’t help the rest.

“With Watchdog Nation, you can see ways to solve your problems beyond complaining to a company or to a newspaper columnist. It’s easier than you think.”

Watchdog Nation’s core principles are these:

  1. Do a background check before buying. Although obvious, many consumers forget to run a simple Internet search before spending money on a product, company or service. Before buying, put the name of the company or product between quotes and add the words “rip-off” and “scam” to the search. If anything pops up, there could be a problem.
  2. Ask a bunch of questions. Don’t assume anything. Example: Starbucks offers three sizes of drinks on its public menu. Actually, there are six different cups available – including a little-known “short” size that is smaller and cheaper than the others. Two other cups are free sample cups. Dig below the surface on all purchases. Ask questions and read up on buying tips and potential problems.
  3. Hold customer service reps accountable. When seeking assistance from a company, know to whom you’re speaking. Get a name, employee ID number and location of call center. Keep a record of the day and time you call and what is said. This information gives you confidence in your dealings and sets you apart from most complaining customers. Even better, tell the company you are taping the call for “customer quality control.”
  4. Find the point of vulnerability. Businesses are like castles. They allow customers in through a front gate – a toll-free number or by e-mail – on their terms. But castles aren’t impregnable. You can still gain entry through other means. By doing Internet research, you can find other customers who experienced similar problems. Maybe there’s a class-action lawsuit or a state attorney general conducting an investigation. Once you learn the company’s vulnerability point, use it to pressure for a more favorable solution. If you need help with research or don’t have a computer, ask your local reference librarian for free assistance.
  5. Apply the pressure point. If you are victimized by a business or scammer, remember that almost everybody is regulated, licensed, audited, inspected, certified or permitted by a local, state or federal government agency. Sometimes, professional associations for various occupations take complaints, too. If a company won’t satisfy your request, complain to whomever regulates them. Ask that agency to conduct an official investigation.

“For the first time in human history, information is quickly available to help you solve your specific problem,” Lieber says. “When you know what to look for, you become a citizen of Watchdog Nation and a superhero who can solve your own problems.”

Company’s defense of sales tactics doesn’t square with complaints

Some chambers of commerce in Texas and across the nation have complained about an Arlington company that sells maps, advertising and other promotional items to chamber members. The problem, these chambers and their members say, is that salespeople for Universal AdCom and its affiliated companies claim they are working for the chambers when they aren’t.

Company officials, however, say they do not engage in deceptive sales practices.

“We try to run a clean ship and operate aboveboard and with integrity, but there are just some individuals that you’re always going to have a beef with,” says Hiram McBeth III, the company’s general counsel. “Believe it or not, when you deal with a high-volume business such as ours, there are some people who try to avoid their debt.”

The Watchdog found that in the past decade, chambers, as well as other government agencies, schools and newspapers, have issued warnings to steer clear of the company in Washington, Vermont, Texas, Oregon, Mississippi, California, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Kansas, West Virginia and South Carolina.

Attorneys general in Arkansas, Illinois and Georgia have taken action against the company. Not so in Texas.

“We have no complaints over the past two years on this company,” says Tom Kelley, spokesman for the Texas attorney general’s office. “No legal action either.”

The Better Business Bureau at Fort Worth gives the company an “F” rating because of complaints. But the BBB’s Web site shows that almost all the complaints — 120 in the past year — have been resolved by the company.

“We’ve done very well, I think,” says McBeth, who adds that he personally works to resolve complaints. “We may have had a few problems a decade ago…Any company has its growing pains. They are certainly straightened out right now.”

John Riggins, head of the Fort Worth BBB, says, “The source of complaints is basically the same thing over and over — businesses complaining about poor quality of products or sales tactics or billing errors.”

The company operates under several names, including Premier Map Co., Hometown Productions, Multi Marketing Corp., D & L Map Service, Gildenblatt Enterprises and Texas High School Publications, the BBB says.

The listed owner is Tom Gildenblatt, who owns two houses in Southlake, according to county tax records. I called him and sent a letter requesting an interview, but he didn’t respond.

Two people I interviewed for this report shared examples of the company’s sales tactics.

Fred Richardson, former owner of a Palestine printing and advertising company that creates chamber maps throughout Texas, said the company tells chamber members they are creating an official chamber map.

A few years ago, he got a call from the company asking whether he wanted to renew his company’s ad in the Palestine map. Richardson didn’t recall buying an ad from the company, so he asked the salesperson to fax him a copy of the ad.

When it arrived, he saw that it was his own ad from a map he had produced for the chamber. His copyright information was included on the fax.

He recalls asking the salesperson, “Do I need to get an attorney?”

The salesperson replied, “I can’t talk to you anymore” and hung up, he says.

He never complained and never filed legal action because his lawyer said legal costs would outweigh any settlement he would receive.

When I interviewed Nancy Wyatt, president of the Auburn Area Chamber of Commerce in Washington state last week, she said she had received a call from the company that morning. The salesperson said that he was moving to Auburn and requested a relocation packet, she said. She recognized the company from her Caller ID.

That’s their tactic to get a list of the chamber members and also see who advertises on their maps and other items, she said.

“They’re hitting our members at the same time we’re doing our legitimate projects,” she says. “We’ve educated our members to the point now that unless they get an e-mail that we’re heading into our project, they know immediately to call the chamber office when they get a call like that.”

A few years ago, she continued, a company rep called her and said, “Nancy at the Auburn Area Chamber sent me to you.”

She recalls replying, “That’s funny. I happen to be Nancy at the Auburn Area Chamber.”

She added, “They’re so blatant.”

McBeth, the company’s general counsel, says the company has a sales agreement with every entity it does business with. I asked him to provide a sample copy of the agreement, but he declined.

Meanwhile, a former saleswoman for the company, Sherrell Mpizion, sued the company last year in Tarrant County district court. She claimed that she was fired because she had complained that she was tired of misrepresenting herself in sales calls “as employees of cities or chambers of commerce.”

In her lawsuit, Mpizion says her boss told her to “be an actress” and “say whatever it takes” to get a sale.

A year ago, the suit claims, she was fired because she was “poison” in the company and had gossiped in the office.

The company, in court papers, denies every allegation in the lawsuit and claims that Mpizion resigned and was not fired. “No evidence exists” to support her lawsuit, McBeth wrote in court papers.

Mpizion’s lawyer, R.S. Rhio, declined to comment.

McBeth calls Mpizion “a disgruntled employee trying to seek extra money in these hard times.”

The case has not yet come to trial.

News researcher Cathy Belcher contributed to this report.

Even those with a claim to fame can have credit card problems

He is the most patient man I know. Jim Leavelle, the retired Dallas police detective who was handcuffed to Lee Harvey Oswald the moment Oswald was fatally shot, answers every question about those dark days in November 1963 as if he were hearing them for the first time.

Forty-five years later, Leavelle still wears a replica of the famed Resistol hat at public events when he is asked to talk about history. He is 88 now, retired in Garland, an old-school gentleman who still looks much the same as he did in that legendary photograph of Oswald crumpling to the floor while tethered to him.

Leavelle is always patient with history buffs, but he’s not so patient with his credit card company. A couple of months back, after he had canceled a cookbook he supposedly ordered, American Express kept billing him. He grew so angry that he cut his card into pieces and mailed them to the company.

With that, the owner of one of the most famous faces in American history thought he was through with AmEx. Maybe so, but the company wasn’t done with him.

The bills kept coming for Food and Wine Cookbook, which Leavelle doesn’t remember ordering. Even if he did, he says, he canceled within the allotted time. He was told that everything would get squared away. He’d get a credit on his bill. He never did.

He called again. Same line.

The bills kept coming, and he threw them away. Eventually, his original disputed $35 charge ballooned with interest and penalties to $114.

Soon a collection agency started pestering him. He ignored it, too. That’s when I heard about it.

Admittedly, an 88-year-old man doesn’t need to worry too much about his credit score, which drops when a delinquency, even an inaccurate one, is charged. But surely he doesn’t need the pestering. Especially this guy, who has been pestered his entire adult life because one day, a long time ago, he found himself in the worst place at the worst time.

An American Express spokeswoman confirmed that Leavelle had properly tried to cancel the cookbook and asked for the refund. But the refund request, which was approved, never went through, the spokeswoman said, because a third-party vendor sells the books.

“He’s correct,” spokeswoman Marina Hoffmann said. “He canceled us. He wanted it refunded. Obviously, looking at it, it was very clear that the customer was not at fault.”

Yet nothing he tried worked. Then Leavelle was so agitated that he pushed it aside, even though he was in the right.

I asked Hoffmann what a customer is supposed to do.

“Just be persistent,”Hoffmann said.”I realize he spoke to three different people. It’s kind of a lesson for your readers. To be vigilant and make sure that customer service follows through with what they promise you.”

See, everybody? It’s our fault now.

Leavelle’s credit report was cleared of the supposed delinquency. His credit card, though, is in pieces and long gone.

Don’t give up when a company is sending you bills that are unfair or inaccurate.

When buying through a credit card company that works with a third-party vendor, cancel with both the credit card company and the vendor, if possible.

After canceling, check your free annual credit report to verify that the cancellation didn’t mar your record. Get one free credit report every year at www.annualcreditreport.com.